First of all, I would like to establish that I hate Nicki Minaj. And the LSS on this song is really annoying. So I might as well share this repulsive title (and tune) with all of you to lighten up the mood (assuming that there will be people who will continue to read this after seeing the title)
“Philosophy is an attempt to render intelligible our experience of reality that
cannot be equated with words”
This was the line in this morning’s lecture that struck me the most. I kind of agree, because I like telling stories to my friends, and I like “sharing my experiences” with them. And at some point, we have all told stories and we try our best when we do so because we want them to experience the same things we went through. We want to show them what happened, who were involved, how we reacted, and what we reacted to. We may get a few laughs here, there and everywhere, even some mixed reactions and opinions, but the fact of the matter is, we can never really capture the essence of that experience in its entirety. And that, I think is the most frustrating thing a person telling a story will ever and always go through. The unexplainable reality of that experience, for the story teller, is a trap.
It is like a trap, a story telling trap. Da beez are the story tellerz, beez in da trap.
When you tell your stories, you want to make it as lively as possible, as if it were happening here and now, as if you were reliving that specific moment. But when you tell the story and the person you are telling it to has no reactions, or worse -- bad reactions, you have failed as a story teller. Not only did you fail in making the experience become imaginable to that person, but you actually ruined it for him/her.
Back to the point -- no matter how good of a story teller you are, no matter how good you deliver a punch line that someone else told as a joke, or no matter how much you exaggerate one teeny tiny detail just to make the experience as live and as fresh as possible, what you say can never really express the actual reality of what you went through and what you felt during that moment. Those events, those experiences, are somehow beyond words. To sum it all up, what you can say when someone asks you about a certain event or moment and you do not know how to tell that story (or if you are just so awful at it that you actually ruin those experiences for them), then you can simply go and answer “you just had to be there.”
On this note, I somehow find it interesting that we, as human beings try to make the things we experience understandable to others. That as much as possible, we want to explain and narrate to them the specifics of certain events, because in truth, we want to (or at least, wanted to) share those experiences with them. Share, not only in the sense of storytelling, but to actually go through those same kinds of experiences; to experience the joy, the despair, the laughter, the excitement (or whatever) with them. We want to share with the people that we tell these stories to, the same feelings and reactions, and in a sense, literally share those same kinds of experiences just so we won’t have to go through the always inadequate “sharing” of these experiences through mere stories.
Because once we’ve experienced these new things with the people we want to, we talk about it with them; we enter into dialogue, we give our own perspectives of what happened, what we felt, what caught our attention; and in return, they give theirs. And it is through these conversations that that experience, somehow becomes more alive in our stories. When we tell these stories to other people, we tell it alongside the ones we experienced them with, and we tell them a little bit closer, this time, to the actual reality of that moment, rather than it being told by one babbling story teller in an awful (but amusing) attempt to share experiences with others through nothing but simple words.
I think that storytelling is an important part of forming identities. We make sense of our lives and its many random turns through making a narrative out of it. New experiences change how we view past experiences. But it's hard to actually capture the "essence" of the experience in a way that re-tells the experience faithfully.
ReplyDeleteI like the point you made about talking about a shared experience with someone you shared that experience with because while it is true that storytelling can cheapen experience, talking about a shared experience makes that experience "more alive", it gives it an added depth.
- Veronica Jereza (C)
Yes I also find myself having difficulty in telling stories to others, it's like I want to add more and more details into the story, but just to figure out that I can never end my story by this way. Even if you are telling a specific experience with the people that have experienced the same thing, your interpretation or perspective to it might not be the same, because each individual has his/her own different perspective towards life experience. Therefore, we should recognize that this world is made up of variety of meanings, and that there are infinitely many "worlds" that exist in this world. When we recognize that each one of us have a different perspective even to the universal truth, we are being conscious that we are being with others, that we are a part of a larger whole.
ReplyDeleteSo, Wai Yiu (A)
I believe that there is no perfect translation for words the same way, we cannot recreate an event in our lives exactly by retelling it. It won't be as accurate, but once we go into dialogue with people, we somewhat share a part of us, and they too, in return, share their experience. Through these dialogues we light our paths to the truth.
ReplyDeleteDiane Cheng (C)
I completely agree with you that no matter how you tell a certain experience to a person, how much you explain how that experience really means to you, or whatsoever, that person you told your story to wouldn't completely comprehend what that something really is, unless you have the same experiences. But then, because of our different perceptions, our different ways of thinking, we translate the experiences we have differently. However, through opening the lines of communication, we open ourselves to sharing our experiences with others and thus, opening ourselves to the different perceptions of others too.
ReplyDeleteTrixia Tan (C)